Home » Deciphering the Significance of Foo Fighters’ Muppet-Metal Masterpiece: “The Pretender”

Deciphering the Significance of Foo Fighters’ Muppet-Metal Masterpiece: “The Pretender”

When Foo Fighters unleashed their sixth album, “Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace,” in September 2007, they had already spent the preceding 12 years solidifying their presence on rock radio and in packed arenas. Despite occasionally using his platform to support political causes, Dave Grohl, the main creative force and face of Foo Fighters, predominantly directed his lyrics towards personal rather than political themes.

In the compelling first single from “Echoes, Silence, Patience & Grace,” titled “The Pretender,” Grohl and his bandmates seem to be making a statement that transcends the powerful assault of their guitars, the urgency of the late Taylor Hawkins’ beat, and Grohl’s intense vocal delivery. While Grohl hasn’t been particularly explicit about the specific message behind the lyrics for “The Pretender,” we can infer much of the meaning from his statements and the song’s lyrics themselves.

What’s Got Grohl So Fired Up?

Grohl hasn’t delved extensively into the inspiration behind writing the lyrics for “The Pretender.” However, in an interview for the British radio station Radio X (formerly known as XFM), he mentioned, “I think a lot of people feel f—ed over right now and they’re not getting what they were promised, and so (it has) something to do with that.”

Considering that the song was penned in the late spring of 2007, it’s plausible that Grohl was channeling the public’s discontent, particularly towards President George W. Bush, whose approval ratings had plummeted to nearly 30 percent. At that time, the subprime mortgage crisis was unfolding, the U.S. economy teetered on the brink of recession, and Bush had deployed additional troops to Iraq earlier in the year.

The lyrics of the song don’t explicitly pinpoint the specific target of Grohl’s frustration, but it’s evident that it extends beyond an individual in a personal relationship. The initial lyrics in the quiet intro allude to a larger malevolent force: “Keep you in the dark You know they all pretend Keep you in the dark And so it all began”

As the band kicks in for the first verse, Grohl makes another reference to a vaguely defined “them” with the lyrics, “Send in your skeletons / Sing as their bones go marchin’ in again.” While it’s not explicitly clear if Grohl is alluding to soldiers being perceived as disposable, later in the song, he unequivocally expresses his belief that those in power regard individuals as mere pawns.

“In time or so I’m told I’m just another soul for sale, oh well The page is out of print We are not permanent, we’re temporary, temporary Same old story” These lyrics provide enough context to paint a picture of the “pretenders” who manipulate and exploit others for their own gain. However, the official video for “The Pretender” by the Foo Fighters, directed by Sam Brown, expands on Grohl’s vision.

The video showcases the band performing the song in a vast room with a white floor, while a line of police officers in riot gear stands on the opposite side, separated by a black line on the floor. The video doesn’t explicitly portray the deceit practiced by the powerful; instead, it emphasizes the brute force employed to carry out their true intentions.

The Lighter Side (Sort of) of “The Pretender”

In the chorus, Grohl adopts a defiant stance, calling out “the pretender” and affirming that he will “never surrender.” Interestingly, the brisk lyrics and melody find inspiration from an unexpected and not-so-intimidating source. Foo Fighters guitarist Chris Shiflett pointed out to Grohl that the chorus strongly echoes the Sesame Street song “One of These Things (Is Not Like the Others).” Upon recognizing the similarities, Grohl realized that the children’s song had likely been on his mind, given that he had spent the previous few months at home with the Grohls’ first daughter, Violet.


“The Pretender” marked Foo Fighters’ third Top 40 single, reaching No. 37 on the Billboard Hot 100. However, the song achieved even greater success on Billboard’s Mainstream Rock and Alternative Airplay charts, securing the top spot in both categories. Boasting over half a million views, the official video for “The Pretender” stands as the band’s most popular video on YouTube. With over 700 million streams on Spotify, it trails only “Everlong” in terms of Foo Fighters songs streamed most frequently on the platform.

In 2008, “The Pretender” clinched the Grammy Award for Best Hard Rock Performance and earned Grammy nominations for Record of the Year and Best Rock Song. Among Foo Fighters hits, few match the intensity of “The Pretender.” Despite its fierce nature, the track’s catchiness solidifies its status as one of their most popular and celebrated songs.

Balancing aggression and melodicism is no easy feat, yet Grohl and his bandmates skillfully fused a Sesame Street-inspired melody with some of their most pointed lyrics. It seems there’s little in the realm of musical genres that they can’t conquer, and with “The Pretender,” they can proudly check “Muppet metal” off their list.

<iframe width=”662″ height=”372″ src=”https://www.youtube.com/embed/SBjQ9tuuTJQ” title=”Foo Fighters – The Pretender” frameborder=”0″ allow=”accelerometer; autoplay; clipboard-write; encrypted-media; gyroscope; picture-in-picture; web-share” allowfullscreen></iframe>

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *